Another Look at Markets
On the Clarion board we often discuss markets. A couple guys have stories at Realms of Fantasy and have been waiting over six months with no response — one just got a form rejection after almost nine months.
I’ve only submitted a couple stories to Realms, the last one over eighteen months ago. They’re not really on my radar right now because of the long response times and rumors of frequently misplaced submissions. Clarion grads were also supposed to be plucked from the general slush, but not any more, allegedly. And on top of it all, they only publish six issues a year meaning they buy fewer stories annually than the other “big” markets.
So this got me thinking. How many stories do these markets publish annually?
In an entirely unscientific way, I did some searching on the Internet and put together the below table. It’s not 100% accurate but I think it’s fairly close. Analog, Asimov’s and F&SF share the same format and, unsurprisingly, publish about the same amount of fiction per issue. I did a quick scan of the table of contents for about ten issues for each and since Analog and Asimov’s count their double issue as two, I did the same for F&SF. Strange Horizons and SCIFI.com publish a story a week for the year. I think it’s probably 51 stories a year as I think they take a week off, but what the heck, I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt. Writers of the Future is a quarterly contest with three winners per quarter. The others are some other high-quality markets thrown in for comparison.
“Stories” include flash fiction, short stories, novelettes, novellas, and any part of a serialization.
I also threw in the average wait times for a manuscript based on the reports at Critter’s Black Hole which, in my experience, tend to be pretty accurate. I didn’t include pay but all of them are around 3-6 cents/word.
Again, this is only for a rough idea. For what it’s worth.
| Market |
Issues/Yr
|
Stories/Issue
|
Stories/Yr
|
Avg.
Wait Time |
| F&SF |
12
|
~7
|
84
|
12
days |
| Analog |
12
|
~7
|
84
|
39
days |
| Asimov’s |
12
|
~7
|
84
|
57 days |
| Scifi.com |
52
|
1
|
52
|
56
days |
| Strange Horizons |
52
|
1
|
52
|
33
days |
| Ideomancer |
4
|
12
|
48
|
21
days |
| Realms of Fantasy |
6
|
~6
|
36
|
115
days |
| Lady Churchill’s |
2
|
~14
|
28
|
57
days |
| Chizine |
4
|
4
|
16
|
16
days |
| Fortean Bureau |
4
|
4
|
16
|
38
days |
| Writers of the Future |
4
|
3
|
12
|
115
days |
We publish more than 52pieces of Flash Lit per year. Response speed depends on distance from deadline and on the quality of the piece; a great story might be accepted within minutes; a submission for The Winter Issue (deadline 9/1) might take 90 days. We’re more “literary” than SF/Fantasy/Horror. We don’t use a “form” rejection; we try to explain our rejections and offer suggestions for improvement. Come see what we’ve been doing — http://flashers-dozen.blogspot.com/
Comment by KR Mullin — Fri, Jul 8th, 2005 @ 9:20 pm