Favorite Stories From the Past Year
![]()
For kicks, I went back through my blog and took an inventory of what I’ve been reading this past year. Turns out, it’s quite a lot! Which is terrific, of course. About a year ago, I was fairly immersed in Icelandic Sagas, then hit a bunch of novels recommended by the Clarion crew, and then hit short fiction collections. I’ve been reading short fiction almost exclusively for the last several months, probably because I’m studying it just as much as reading it.
Anyway, I thought I’d post my five favorite stories that I’ve read in the past year. Not all of them were published in the last year, but they’re all within the last couple years. Besides, they were new to me, so there! Seriously, do what you can to check these stories out because they’re all of the highest, highest quality.
Loosely, in order:
#5 - “A Little Learning” by Matthew Hughes - (F&SF, June 2004)
“ALL” was the first Matthew Hughes story I read, but not the last. Like most of Hughes’ work, I found that whatever this story lacked in depth and emotional resonance it made up for it with its sheer entertainment factor. His stories tend be on the longer side, but they never feel like it because of their light tone and hapless protagonists. Hughes has written a bunch of great stories in F&SF over the last few years. I plan on checking out his novels once I get off the short fiction kick I’ve been on. Unlike the other stories on this list, “ALL” didn’t make me stop and think about life for awhile — but when something’s this fun, that’s okay.
#4 - “The New Year’s Party or Dancing on Sleipner’s Bones”
by David Schwartz (Strange Horizons, Dec. 2004)
By far the shortest story on this list at around 1600 words, this story packs an emotional wallop. Norse mythology in general, and Ragnarock specifically, are widely regarded as being suffocatingly depressing but that’s because I think they’re fundamentally misunderstood. For me, both are fundamentally about inevitability tinged with regret. But there’s beauty in this worldview that’s often missed. Regret, inevitability, and even despair can be made instantly inconsequential by a simply seizing a single moment and making it your own. I’m sure a lot of readers don’t get the Norse implications, but that’s what this story says to me. See if that’s what is says to you.
#3 - “People of Sand and Slag” by Paolo Bacigalupi (F&SF, Feb. 2004)
Bacigalupi’s story lost out on the 2005 Hugo Award to Kelly Link’s “The Faerie Handbag,” but personally I preferred this one. I’ve read a couple other stories by Bacigalupi and thoroughly enjoyed them all, but this one takes the proverbial cake. “POSAS” seems to be asking a lot of tough questions about what makes us human and whether we’re “advancing” as a species or just changing, yet (like Schwartz’s story) this story doesn’t directly ask these questions at all. I found it absolutely breathtaking. The fact that emotional attachment to a dog figures in heavily to the plot probably has something to do with that.
#2 - “Magic for Beginners” by Kelly Link (F&SF, Sept. 2005)
What’s to say about this story that hasn’t already been said? Stories rarely grab me so tightly that I feel like I have to finish them right now, this very minute, all other obligations be damned. This story defies labels, genres, and anything else you try to stick to it. By the end of the story you realize you have a lump in your throat but you can’t quite figure out why. Like most everybody on the planet, I found adolescence utterly bewildering, and this golden story did a wonderful job making me feel the highs and lows of those years all over again, and, most of all, the terrifying yet oddly reassuring confusion we never fully outgrow.
#1 - “Present from the Past” by Jeff Ford (The Silver Gryphon, 2003)
Jeff posted this to his website a month or so ago but took it down after a few weeks, as he’s doing with some of his other stuff. A blog is an interesting place to post a story because as you start reading, it’s not quite clear whether its just a weird autobiographical vignette or a work of fiction — or both? So it goes with “Present from the Past” which reminded me of Jeff’s award-winning story “Creation” which has the same autobiographical bent, or “The Honeyed Knot” which Jeff professes is 99% true, despite all the unbelievably weird things that happen. What I find most remarkable in all of these top-class stories is that they’re not fantasy — they’re real life. Some folks just can’t handle that sometimes real life is weirder and more mysterious than we give it credit for. It’s the kind of story that makes me want to quit my job, go home, and sit in a corner of the darkened basement for about a week and just think about life. Magic stuff.
Honorable Mentions:
- Cold Fires by M. Rickert (F&SF, Oct/Nov 2004)
- The Five Cigars of Abu Ali by Eric Schaller (SciFi.com, Jan 2005)
- Man of Light by Jeff Ford (Sci-Fi.com, Jan 2005)
- “The Hortlak” by Kelly Link (The Dark, 2003, and Magic for Beginners, 2005)
Current Mood - Not Bad for a Monday | ![]()
Currently Listening To - Sun Volt - “Trace”


